THIS IS TOO MAMY ENTRIES.
I wanted to present the full idea. So here it is anyway, but I'm primarily suggesting the Spiced Eyernal Pumpkin Loaf and Creepy Eternal Pumpkin Loaf as my trick/treat :)
Category: Treat
Item name (optional): Spiced Eternal Pumpkin Loaf
Type of item: Food/
Sketch or Descr.iption of Appearance: A small loaf in a rectangle, brass tin, attached to it is a little note. Tied with string.
This item is inspired by "Herman" or friendship loaves, which are typically cinnamon and apple loaves, but I think they could easily by a spiced pumpkin bread.
Category: Treat
Item name (optional): Spiced Eternal Pumpkin Mix
Type of item: Openable (I know this isn't an option but bear with me)
Sketch or Descr.iption of Appearance: A glass jar filled with a spiced, yeasty mixture. A lengthy note is attached to the jar. When selected it gives the option to open and it opens up giving three items. Either another jar of the same item or a Spiced Eternal Pumpkin Loaf. Its presented nestly and wrapped in a bow
----
Alternatively along the same lines
Category: Trick
Item name (optional): Creepy Eternal Pumpkin Loaf
Type of item: food
Sketch or Descr.iption of Appearance: A small loaf in a rectangle copper tin. It has creepy jack o' lantern type faces trying to rise out of it.
Flavor text: "This loaf looks like its still trying to split into more loafs. Its got an eerie aura about it, but you are concerned in you don't eat it, something bad might happen. It tastes bitter, like the yeast had sat for too long"
Category: Trick
Item name (optional): Creepy Eternal Pumpkin Mix
Type of item: openable
Sketch or Descr.iption of Appearance: A small jar with the yeasty mixture spilling out messily. In the jar its got that sort of "souls trapped in a bottle" vibe with jack o' lantern type faces pressed up against the glass.
-----
Other names for items based on the same premise. Alternatively the mix openable could be just a generic name succh as Eternal Loaf Mix and it opens to three-five items, and can have either the same item or one of the variety of loaves.
Candy Corn Eternal Loaf - food/Treat
Bonemeal Eternal Loaf - food/Trick
Apple Toffee Eternal Loaf - Food/Treat
Eternal Meatloaf - Food/trick
Forgotten Eternal loaf - Food/Trick (spider-webby and dusty)
Carrot and Fruit Eternal Loaf - Food/Treat