 Lump of Chocolate (x 1) |  Lump of Coal (x 2) |  Madigan Charm (x 1) |
 Madigan Squishy (x 1) |  Madigans Necklace (x 1) |  Magenta Aukira Tail Feathers (x 1) |
 Magenta Carved Crystal Skull (x 1) |  Magenta Present Squishy (x 2) |  Malal Stocking (x 1) |
 Malalslip (x 1) |  Marshmallow Maggots (x 1) |  Marshmallow Skull (x 1) |
 Mashed Sweet Potatoes (x 1) |  Meat Blob Monster (x 1) |  Meaty Taffy (x 1) |
 Meiko Stocking (x 2) |  Meragon Gingerbread Cookie (x 1) |  Meragon Stocking (x 1) |
 Mint Narwi Lance Lolly (x 1) |  Mirabilis Stocking (x 1) |  Missiletoe (x 1) |
 Mistletoe Shield (x 1) |  Mixed Flavor Jelly Beans (x 1) |  More Fish In Atquati Card (x 1) |
 Mummy Wrapped Lolly (x 1) |  Murren Gingerbread Cookie (x 1) |  Murren Stocking (x 2) |
 Myotis Oni Mask (x 1) |  Myotis Stocking (x 1) |  Mystery Jaaku Lolli (x 1) |
 Narwi Gingerbread Cookie (x 1) |  Narwi Pillow (x 1) |  Narwi Stocking (x 1) |
 Natural Aukira Tail Feathers (x 1) |  Natural Iluvu Gloves (x 7) |  Noctis Gingerbread Cookie (x 1) |
 Noctis Head (x 1) |  Noctis Stocking (x 1) |  Not Good At Love Card (x 1) |
 Noxious Perfume (x 1) |  Odd Color Fish (x 1) |  Omni Stocking (x 2) |
 Orange Gummy Bat (x 1) |  Orange Gummy Rat (x 1) |  Orange Halloween Sweet (x 1) |
 Orange Halloween Trick or Treat Sweet (x 1) |  Orange Jaaku Grin Mask (x 1) |  Orchid Aukira Tail Feathers (x 2) |
 Orchid Carved Crystal Skull (x 1) |  Orchid Present Squishy (x 2) |  Orchsearo (x 1) |
 Orchsearo Seedling (x 1) |  Otachie Stocking (x 1) |  Otachitail Seed Cluster (x 1) |
 Otachitails (x 1) |  PAB Contest Marble (x 1) |  Painted Easero Egg (x 1) |
 Painted Kurrabi Egg (x 1) |  Painted Otachie Egg (x 1) |  Panda Bear Squishy (x 1) |
 Paor Stocking (x 1) |  Paordula (x 1) |  Paordula Sprout (x 1) |
 Partially-Eaten Drumstick (x 1) |  Patched Book Squishy (x 1) |  Patrick Goody Bag 08 (x 1) |
 Perilus (x 1) |  Perilus Seed (x 1) |  Pine Bow (x 1) |
 Pine Cone Bird Treat (x 1) |  Pine Sweater (x 1) |  Pinecone Hat (x 2) |
 Pink Broken Heart Shards (x 1) |  Pink Double Bow (x 1) |  Pink Halloween Sweet (x 1) |
 Pink Rock Candy Heart (x 1) |  Pink Valentine Card (x 1) |  Piranha Gummy (x 1) |
 Pitchcu Plant (x 1) |  Plain Resuccino (x 1) |  Poinsettias (x 1) |
 Poison Apple (x 1) |  Polar Bear Squishy (x 1) |  Pop Up Madigan Toy (x 1) |
 Post Apocalyptic Blood Stains (x 1) |  Post Apocalyptic Pack (x 1) |  Pot of Gold Charm (x 1) |
 Potato Gun (x 1) |  Potion of Death (x 1) |  Potion of Knowledge (x 1) |
 Puffy Jack-o-Lantern Top (x 1) |  Pumpkin Cirrus Candy (x 1) |  Pumpkin Gummy Vitamins (x 1) |
 Pumpkin Guts (x 1) |  Pumpkin Icing Voodoo Cookie (x 1) |  Pumpkin Lollipop (x 1) |
 Pumpkin Spice Muffin (x 1) |  Pumpkin Spice Taffy (x 1) |  Pumpkin-Shaped Chocolate (x 1) |
 Purple Broken Heart Shards (x 1) |